Amerisleep Organica Plush Mattress Review
Our accomplished team of sleep science coaches, engineers, and product evaluators meticulously assess hundreds of mattresses using our unique product methodology. Each article is reviewed for precision, citing only credible sources. Systematically reassessing our content and picks, we align with the latest scientific literature and expert counsel. Our top-rated mattresses have been personally assessed and highly rated.

Freshly Re-evaluated
We've recently updated our top mattress picks, incorporating new insights from our professional testers. If a mattress appears on this list, you can be sure that we've personally assessed it and granted it a high rating based on our stringent evaluation standards.
Key Takeaways
- Natural Luxury at a Premium: The mattress combines high-end natural materials (including 6 inches of Talalay latex, organic cotton, and wool) in a luxurious 16-inch profile. While its price tag is significant, the mattress offers exceptional durability and eco-friendly construction that justify the investment for the right buyer.
- Ideal for Side Sleepers and Natural Material Enthusiasts: With a soft 4/10 firmness rating, the mattress excels at pressure relief for side sleepers and those who prefer a plush feel. Its natural latex construction provides responsive support without the “stuck” feeling of memory foam.
- Strong Test Performance in Key Areas: The mattress earned impressive scores across critical categories. This performance, combined with high-quality natural materials and strong environmental certifications, earned it a final overall rating of 9/10 despite its premium price point and specific firmness preferences.
While many premium mattresses rely on synthetic foams and chemical treatments, the Organica Plush takes a different approach, using materials like natural latex harvested from rubber trees, organic cotton, and wool from ethically raised sheep. The result is a 16-inch tall masterpiece that aims to provide cloud-like comfort without compromising on support or sustainability.
As a certified sleep coach who has tested hundreds of mattresses, I was particularly excited to evaluate the Amerisleep Organica Plush, a luxury mattress that promises to deliver both supreme comfort and environmental responsibility.
Now, I can’t claim that this mattress is a small investment. But considering we spend about a third of our lives in bed, choosing the right mattress might be one of the most important decisions we make for our daily comfort and wellbeing.
So the question is: does the Organica Plush deliver enough value to justify its premium price tag?
I evaluated every aspect of this mattress, from how it handles different sleep positions to how well it regulates temperature on warm nights. I checked its edge support while putting on shoes in the morning and assessed its motion isolation when my partner tossed and turned at night.
I wanted to discover not just how it performs, but who it’s best suited for and whether its natural materials make a real difference in sleep quality.
In this detailed review, I’ll share everything I learned about the Organica Plush, helping you understand if this eco-friendly luxury mattress might be the key to better sleep in your home.
Let’s explore what sets this mattress apart and whether its natural approach to comfort lives up to the hype.
Mattress Layers, Materials, and Construction
Unboxing the Organica Plush was quite the experience. Despite its impressive size, Amerisleep’s compression technology allows it to arrive in a manageable box, though you’ll definitely want a partner to help move it.
As I carefully cut away the plastic wrapping, the mattress began to expand with a gentle whoosh. Though, notably without the chemical smell that often accompanies new mattresses. Instead, there was just a subtle, natural scent from the organic materials.
Let me walk you through its construction, which rose before me like a carefully orchestrated symphony of eco-friendly layers to its full 16-inch height. It’s like the luxury SUV of mattresses, commanding attention while promising both comfort and performance.
Starting at the surface, there’s a cover made with organic cotton that feels like sleeping on a cloud crafted from long-strand fibers. The top is knitted for extra softness while the sides are woven for durability. This thoughtful touch creates a gentle landing place for tired bodies while ensuring the mattress maintains its structure over time.
Just beneath lies a layer of organic wool that serves as nature’s own temperature regulator. Like a vigilant guardian, it keeps you cool in summer and cozy in winter.
This wool layer also acts as a natural fire barrier, eliminating the need for chemical flame retardants or fiberglass. When I run my hand across a sample of it, there’s a subtle plushness that whispers of comfort without overwhelming.
The crown jewel of this mattress is its generous helping of natural Talalay latex. The plush model features a luxurious 6 inches total of latex, including a 3-inch box top that sets it apart from its medium-feel sibling.
Then, two more layers of latex, a 2-inch soft layer and a 1-inch medium layer working in harmony with the box top. When I lie down, it’s like being embraced by a cloud that knows exactly how to support each curve and contour of my body. The latex responds with a gentle bounce that never feels jarring—more like floating than sinking.
The breathability of the latex (up to seven times more breathable than traditional foams) combines with the temperature-regulating properties of the wool and the airflow through the coil system to create a sleep environment that stays remarkably comfortable throughout the night. It’s like having your own personal climate control system built right into your bed.
At the heart of the mattress lies an 8-inch pocketed coil system that serves as its backbone. These individually wrapped coils dance independently, responding to movement with precision while maintaining whisper-quiet operation.
The edge support is particularly impressive, with reinforced coils around the perimeter that make sitting on the side feel as stable as any other part of the mattress.
One detail I particularly appreciate is the 1-inch wool border around the coil system. It’s a subtle touch that helps the mattress maintain its shape and adds to its overall durability.
The addition of handles along the sides makes moving this 16-inch masterpiece much more manageable, though it’s still a substantial piece that commands respect when being repositioned.
The overall effect is a mattress that feels both indulgently plush and surprisingly supportive. When I sink into it at night, it’s as if the mattress understands exactly how to cradle my body without letting me sink too deeply.
It’s the kind of comfort that makes you sigh contentedly as you drift off to sleep, knowing you’re resting on materials that are as kind to the planet as they are to your body.
Sleep Positions
The way a mattress performs across different sleep positions is one of the most crucial aspects of its overall assessment. After all, a mattress that excels for one sleep position but fails at others might be perfect for some sleepers but completely unsuitable for others.
How a mattress responds to different sleep positions helps you determine if it will meet your specific needs. When evaluating the Organica Plush across different sleep positions, I considered several key factors for each position:
- For side sleeping, I focused on pressure relief at the shoulders and hips.
- For back sleeping, I paid attention to lower back support and spinal alignment.
- Stomach sleeping required careful evaluation of hip positioning and overall body alignment.
- And for combination sleeping, I assessed both the comfort in each position and the ease of transitioning between them.
I also considered how different body weights might experience each position differently, as the plush surface of this mattress can create varying levels of support depending on your body type.
What I discovered through this testing was that while the Organica Plush excels in certain positions, particularly side sleeping, it may not be the ideal choice for all sleep styles. This isn’t unusual, by the way. Most mattresses have positions where they perform better than others.
Side Sleeping
As a primary side sleeper myself, I paid particular attention to how the mattress handled this position. When side sleeping, the key areas to evaluate are shoulder and hip pressure relief, as these points bear the most weight and are common sources of discomfort.
The Organica Plush excelled as a mattress for side sleeping, earning its highest position-specific scores here. The 3-inch latex box top, combined with the additional latex comfort layers, created what I call a “cloud zone.”
My shoulders and hips sink in just enough to maintain proper spinal alignment while preventing any pressure points. Think of it like having a perfectly-sized groove carved out for your body’s curves.
I tested both sides, spending several hours in various side-sleeping positions. The mattress responded particularly well to the fetal position, where pressure points are typically most pronounced.
Even after several hours, I experienced no numbness or tingling in my shoulders or arms. A common issue with firmer mattresses. The latex’s responsive nature also made it easy to change positions without feeling stuck.
Back Sleeping
Back sleeping requires a different kind of support than side sleeping. The mattress needs to maintain the natural curve of your spine while preventing your hips from sinking too deeply. I spent several nights testing this position, paying close attention to lower back support and overall body alignment.
The Organica Plush performed admirably here, though not quite as perfectly as with side sleeping. The plush surface allowed my lower back to settle into a natural position, with the latex layers and pocketed coils providing sufficient support to prevent excessive sinking.
Think of it like floating on a supportive cloud. You sink in slightly, but there’s always firm support beneath.
However, some back sleepers, particularly those over 200 pounds, might find the plush surface a bit too soft. During my testing, I noticed that while initial comfort was excellent, after several hours there was slightly more hip sinkage than ideal for optimal back sleeping alignment.
Stomach Sleeping
Stomach sleeping is typically the most challenging position for a plush mattress, and my testing confirmed this with the Organica Plush. When sleeping on your stomach, your body needs to maintain a relatively flat position to prevent lower back strain.
During my stomach sleeping tests, I noticed that the plush surface allowed my hips to sink more deeply than ideal for this position. Think of it like trying to maintain a straight line while lying on a soft pillow—eventually, the middle starts to dip.
While the responsive latex and supportive coils prevented complete misalignment, I would hesitate to recommend this mattress to dedicated stomach sleepers, especially those carrying extra weight in their midsection.
Combination Sleeping
For combination sleepers who switch positions throughout the night, I performed what I call the “rotation test.” Deliberately changing positions every 30 minutes to evaluate ease of movement and consistent comfort across positions.
The Organica Plush showed impressive versatility here. The responsive nature of the Talalay latex made position changes effortless. None of that “quicksand feeling” you might get with memory foam.
The mattress adapted quickly to each new position, providing appropriate support and pressure relief whether I moved from side to back or back to side.
The one caveat for combination sleepers would be if stomach sleeping is part of your regular rotation. While occasional stomach sleeping is manageable, those who frequently switch to this position might find the plush surface less than ideal for extended periods in that position.
Mattress Responsiveness
Responsiveness refers to how quickly a mattress responds to movement and recovers its shape. Think of it like the difference between moving through mud vs dirt. Wet dirt holds your footprint while dry dirt quickly returns to its original form.
A responsive mattress makes it easier to move around, change positions during sleep, and avoid feeling “stuck” in the bed. After extensive testing of the Amerisleep Organica Plush’s responsiveness, I rate it an impressive 9 out of 10.
I conducted several systematic tests to evaluate the Organica Plush’s responsiveness. First, I performed what I call the “weighted ball test,” where I drop a 10-pound weight onto different areas of the mattress surface and time how quickly it returns to shape.
The Organica Plush impressed me by bouncing back within just over a second. It was slightly slower than the original Organica but still remarkably quick for a plush mattress.
Next, I conducted the “position transition test,” where I flip-flopped through different sleep positions (side, back, stomach) every 30 seconds for 5 minutes. This simulates the natural movement we make during sleep.
The Talalay latex layers in the Organica Plush created a buoyant feeling that made these transitions smooth and effortless. Rather than fighting against the mattress like you might with slow-responding memory foam, the surface gently assists your movements.
I also performed what I call the “midnight snack test.” As you might expect, this is me getting up from and returning to the bed multiple times, as one might during a restless night.
The mattress immediately readjusted to support my body each time I returned, with no delayed response or temporary indentations that needed time to recover.
The 9/10 score reflects how the Organica Plush achieves this high responsiveness while still maintaining its luxuriously soft feel. The natural Talalay latex is key here. It provides immediate push-back and shape recovery while the pocketed coils add another layer of responsive support.
The only reason it doesn’t get a perfect 10 is that the plush box top creates a slightly deeper initial cushioning that minutely slows the immediate response compared to firmer mattresses.
This level of responsiveness is particularly important for several types of sleepers:
- Combination sleepers who change positions frequently will appreciate how the mattress works with them rather than against them.
- Couples will find it easier to move without disturbing their partner’s side of the bed.
- And those with mobility issues will find it easier to get in and out of bed thanks to the quick-responding surface.
The responsiveness also contributes to temperature regulation, as a responsive surface allows you to move more freely and prevent heat buildup in one spot. This adds to the natural cooling properties of the latex and organic materials used in the mattress’s construction.
Mattress Motion Isolation
When you share a bed, every time your partner shifts position, gets up for a midnight snack, or returns from a late-night bathroom visit, their movement could potentially disturb your sleep.
Over the course of a night, these small disruptions can significantly impact your sleep quality, even if you don’t fully wake up. Good motion isolation prevents these movements from rippling across the mattress surface, helping both partners maintain deeper, more restful sleep.
And after extensive testing, I’m pleased to award the Amerisleep Organica Plush a perfect 10 out of 10 for motion isolation.
To evaluate the Organica Plush’s motion isolation capabilities, I conducted several practical tests that simulate real-world scenarios. First, I performed what I call the “Water Glass Test.” That’s a glass of water on one side of the mattress and conducting various movements on the other side.
Despite vigorous movement, including jumping onto the bed and changing positions rapidly, the water in the glass barely rippled. This demonstrates how effectively the mattress absorbs and dampens motion.
Next, I conducted the “Sleep Partner Simulation Test.” While one person lay still trying to “sleep,” another person performed a series of typical nighttime movements: getting in and out of bed, changing positions, and even tossing and turning vigorously.
The “sleeping” partner reported feeling virtually no movement transfer. The mattress’s combination of the plush latex box top and pocketed coils proved remarkably effective at containing motion to its point of origin.
I also performed the “Weighted Drop Test,” where I dropped a 10-pound weight at various distances from a sensitive accelerometer to measure motion transfer scientifically.
The results were impressive—movement was almost completely undetectable just 12 inches away from the impact point. This level of motion isolation surpasses what I typically see even in memory foam mattresses, which are often considered the gold standard for motion isolation.
The plush latex box top acts as the first line of defense, absorbing initial impact and movement. The additional latex comfort layers further dampen any remaining motion. Finally, the individually wrapped coils prevent any residual movement from traveling through the support core of the mattress.
For couples with different sleep schedules, light sleepers, or those who tend to move frequently during the night, this level of motion isolation can be transformative for sleep quality.
It means one partner can change positions or leave the bed without causing even minimal disturbance to the other’s sleep. And consequently, both partners’ sleep quality over time.
The perfect 10/10 score is particularly noteworthy because achieving excellent motion isolation in a responsive latex hybrid mattress can be challenging. Usually, the very properties that make latex responsive and bouncy can also transfer motion more readily.
However, the Organica Plush’s innovative construction (a 3-inch latex box top and individually wrapped coils) creates a unique motion-dampening system that excels at absorbing movement.
Mattress Edge Support
Without proper edge support, this simple activity becomes uncomfortable and potentially unstable.
Imagine trying to balance on the edge of a mattress that compresses deeply under your weight, almost like sitting on the edge of a hammock.
Edge support also plays a vital role in sleep quality, especially for couples sharing a bed. Think about a queen-size mattress. Without strong edge support, the usable sleep surface becomes significantly smaller since neither person can comfortably rest near the edges. In essence, poor edge support turns your queen bed into more of a full-size sleeping area.
For those with mobility issues or physical limitations, edge support becomes even more critical. Getting in and out of bed requires a stable surface to push against. Weak edges can make this daily task challenging or even unsafe.
It’s similar to trying to get up from a soft couch versus a firm chair; the stable surface makes the movement much easier and more secure.
Edge support also affects the mattress’s longevity. Over time, weak edges can lead to premature sagging around the perimeter, which not only reduces the usable sleep surface but can also affect the overall structural integrity of the mattress. Think of it like a book with a damaged spine.
The edge support on the Amerisleep Organica Plush deserves special recognition, earning a perfect 10 out of 10 in my testing. When I sit on the edge to put on my shoes in the morning, I notice none of the sagging or instability that often plagues softer mattresses.
Instead, the edge maintains its structure admirably, providing a stable seating surface that feels just as supportive as the center of the mattress.
This is particularly impressive given the plush nature of the comfort layers. Usually, softer mattresses compromise edge support for comfort, but the Organica Plush refuses to make this trade-off.
The reinforced edges also shine during sleep scenarios. When I lie near the perimeter, I feel just as supported as I do in the center of the mattress, with no sensation of roll-off or instability.
This effectively makes every inch of the mattress usable for sleep, which is especially valuable for couples sharing a queen size or for those who tend to spread out during the night.
The stable edge support also makes it easier to get in and out of bed, as you can push off from a firm surface rather than feeling like you’re trying to launch yourself from a marshmallow.
Even when subjected to more demanding edge tests (like standing on the perimeter to make the bed or placing heavy weights along the edges) the Organica Plush maintains its structural integrity.
The combination of the reinforced coil system and the natural resilience of the Talalay latex creates edges that refuse to buckle under pressure.
This durability suggests that the excellent edge support will persist throughout the mattress’s lifespan, rather than deteriorating over time as can happen with less robustly constructed mattresses.
In my extensive experience testing mattresses, I rarely award softer models a perfect 10 for edge support. However, the Organica Plush earns this score by delivering edge support that rivals or surpasses many firmer mattresses, all while maintaining its luxuriously plush comfort level.
It’s a testament to how thoughtful engineering can solve what was once considered an inevitable compromise in mattress design.
Coolness and Breathability
Our bodies naturally cool down as part of the sleep process. We need to drop our core temperature by about 2-3 degrees Fahrenheit to initiate and maintain quality sleep.
A mattress that retains too much heat can interfere with this natural cooling process, leading to restless nights and poor sleep quality. Even that small difference of a few degrees can make it difficult to get or stay comfortable.
I put the Organica Plush through several real-world cooling tests to evaluate its temperature regulation. The mattress excels in this area, earning an impressive 9 out of 10 in my cooling tests.
First, I conducted what I call the “Heat Retention Test.” Which is just me lying on the mattress for 30 minutes and then quickly getting up to measure how quickly the surface temperature returned to room temperature using an infrared thermometer.
The Organica Plush impressed me by cooling down within just a few minutes, significantly faster than memory foam mattresses I’ve tested.
Next, I performed the “Blanket Burrito Test.” This is a cozy and favorite test of mine, wrapping myself in a thick comforter for 15 minutes before suddenly removing it. This simulates the kind of temperature fluctuations many of us experience during sleep.
The mattress responded admirably, quickly dissipating the accumulated body heat rather than holding onto it like many softer mattresses tend to do.
The “Partner Heat Test” involved two people sleeping on the mattress, paying particular attention to the temperature in areas where bodies were in close contact or overlapping. Even in these high-heat zones, the Organica Plush maintained comfortable temperature levels without creating noticeable hot spots.
Several design elements contribute to this excellent cooling performance. The natural Talalay latex used in the comfort layers is inherently more breathable than synthetic foams. As I’ve mentioned, it’s up to seven times more breathable, according to testing.
Think of it like a mesh athletic shirt compared to a thicker cotton t-shirt—the open cell structure allows for significantly better airflow.
The organic wool layer acts as a natural temperature regulator, wicking away moisture and helping maintain comfortable sleep temperatures in both warm and cool conditions. It’s nature’s own climate control system, effectively moving moisture away from your body as you sleep.
The organic cotton cover enhances the cooling properties by providing excellent breathability while feeling cool to the touch. The pocketed coil support system also plays a crucial role, creating channels for air movement throughout the mattress’s core.
The only reason the Organica Plush doesn’t receive a perfect 10 is that its plush surface creates more body contact than firmer mattresses, which can lead to slightly more heat retention in direct contact areas.
However, this is a minor consideration given how effectively the natural materials work together to regulate temperature.
For hot sleepers or those living in warmer climates, the Organica Plush offers a compelling solution to night-time overheating.
Its combination of naturally cooling materials and thoughtful design makes it one of the best-performing plush mattresses I’ve tested for temperature regulation, proving that you don’t have to sacrifice coolness for comfort.
Material Durability and Mattress Longevity
The durability of a mattress affects more than just its physical condition. It impacts your long-term sleep quality, health, and financial investment. A mattress that maintains its support and comfort characteristics longer provides more consistent sleep quality over time.
Furthermore, when you consider the premium price point of the Organica Plush, its longevity directly affects its value proposition and cost per year of use.
Based on material quality, construction methods, and historical performance of similar mattresses, I estimate the Organica Plush could last between 7-10 years while maintaining its essential comfort and support characteristics.
However, this prediction comes with several important caveats. The mattress is relatively new to the market, so we don’t have extensive long-term user data to verify these predictions. We’re extrapolating from our knowledge of the materials and similar constructions.
And real-world usage varies dramatically between owners. Factors like body weight, sleep position, room temperature, humidity levels, and even how frequently you rotate the mattress can significantly impact its lifespan.
Or in other words, a mattress that might last 10 years for one person could show signs of wear much sooner for another.
Material Analysis
The Organica Plush’s primary comfort layers consist of natural Talalay latex, which historically demonstrates excellent durability compared to synthetic foams.
Natural latex typically maintains its shape and supportive properties longer than memory foam or polyfoam, showing less compression over time. Like a high-quality spring that maintains its bounce even after years of compression cycles.
The 6 total inches of latex in the Organica Plush (including the 3-inch box top) provide substantial material depth, which typically correlates with better longevity. When one layer begins to show wear, the others can help maintain overall support and comfort.
However, the plush nature of these layers means they may compress more quickly than firmer latex formulations.
The pocketed coil support system also plays a crucial role in longevity. These coils are designed to maintain their tension and support over time, with the reinforced edge support helping to prevent premature sagging around the perimeter.
Based on industry standards and similar constructions, we would expect these coils to maintain their integrity for 7-10 years under normal use.
Signs of Normal Aging vs. Premature Wear
Understanding how to distinguish between normal aging and premature wear helps set realistic expectations. Normal aging might include:
- Slight softening of the comfort layers over time
- Minor compression in primary sleep areas
- Subtle changes in the mattress’s response to movement
Signs of premature wear that might indicate durability issues:
- Significant sagging or indentations deeper than 1.5 inches
- Uneven support across the surface
- Degradation of edge support
- Noticeable changes in comfort or support within the first few years
Maximizing Longevity
To help achieve maximum lifespan:
- Use a high-quality mattress protector to guard against moisture and stains
- Rotate the mattress every 3-4 months
- Ensure proper support from your bed frame or foundation
- Maintain appropriate room temperature and humidity levels
- Address any spills or stains promptly for a clean mattress
- Follow manufacturer care instructions carefully
While predicting exact durability remains challenging, understanding these factors helps set realistic expectations and implement proper care practices to maximize your mattress’s lifespan.
The Organica Plush’s use of high-quality, natural materials suggests good potential for longevity, but as with any mattress, its actual lifespan will depend significantly on individual use patterns and care practices.
Environmental Impact
The environmental impact of production and materials is becoming an increasingly critical consideration in today’s climate-conscious world. Understanding the implications of mattress production is particularly relevant given that the bedding industry has traditionally been associated with significant environmental challenges.
Conventional mattresses often rely heavily on petroleum-based foams, chemical flame retardants, and synthetic materials that can persist in landfills for centuries.
They frequently involve manufacturing processes that release volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and require extensive use of chemical adhesives.
When we examine a luxury mattress like the Organica Plush, we need to consider not just its immediate comfort and performance, but also its broader ecological footprint. From raw material sourcing to eventual disposal.
Material Sourcing and Production
The Organica Plush’s environmental story begins with its raw materials. The natural Talalay latex comes from rubber trees, which can be sustainably harvested for decades. These trees act as carbon sinks during their productive life, absorbing CO2 from the atmosphere.
The harvesting process is particularly gentle. Rather than cutting down trees, it involves carefully tapping them for sap, allowing them to continue growing and serving their ecological function.
The organic cotton used in the cover represents another thoughtful environmental choice. Organic cotton farming uses significantly less water than conventional cotton and eliminates the use of harmful pesticides and synthetic fertilizers.
This not only reduces the environmental impact but also helps maintain soil health and biodiversity. The GOTS certification ensures these sustainable practices are followed throughout the entire cotton production process.
The wool layer presents an interesting environmental trade-off. While sheep farming does have an environmental impact, including methane emissions and land use, wool is a renewable resource that provides natural fire resistance without the need for chemical treatments.
The wool in the Organica Plush comes from sheep raised under OEKO-TEX® standards, ensuring ethical farming practices that minimize environmental impact.
Manufacturing and Transportation
Amerisleep’s manufacturing process for the Organica Plush emphasizes efficiency and waste reduction. The company claims their manufacturing produces zero air emissions, a significant achievement in an industry often associated with high energy consumption and chemical emissions.
The hand-tufting process used to secure the layers eliminates the need for chemical adhesives, further reducing the environmental impact.
The company’s compression technology for shipping is particularly noteworthy from an environmental perspective.
By compressing the mattress, they can fit three times as many units in a delivery truck compared to traditional shipping methods. This results in an estimated 80% reduction in transportation-related carbon emissions.
However, it’s worth noting that the mattress’s substantial weight (due to its natural materials and 16-inch height) does mean more fuel is required per unit compared to lighter synthetic mattresses.
Certifications and Standards
The Organica Plush boasts impressive environmental credentials:
- GOTS (Global Organic Textile Standard) certification ensures organic standards are met throughout the textile production process
- Rainforest Alliance certification verifies sustainable forestry practices for latex production
- OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 certification confirms the absence of harmful substances
- eco-INSTITUT certification validates low emissions and chemical safety
These certifications provide third-party verification of environmental claims, helping to prevent greenwashing and ensure accountability.
Long-Term Environmental Considerations
The durability of the Organica Plush has important environmental implications. With an expected lifespan of 7-10 years or more, it requires less frequent replacement than many conventional mattresses.
This means fewer resources used over time and less waste entering landfills. The natural materials used are also biodegradable, unlike synthetic foams that can persist in landfills for centuries.
However, the mattress’s size and weight can make recycling more challenging. When the time comes for disposal, consumers may need to seek out specialized recycling facilities capable of handling natural latex mattresses.
Amerisleep could potentially improve their environmental impact by developing a more comprehensive end-of-life recycling program.
Future Considerations
The increasing popularity of eco-friendly mattresses like the Organica Plush may help drive industry-wide changes. As more consumers demand sustainable options, other manufacturers may be encouraged to adopt similar practices.
This could lead to:
- Expanded sustainable rubber tree cultivation
- Growth in organic cotton farming
- Development of more efficient shipping methods
- Innovation in natural fire barriers
- Improved recycling infrastructure for natural mattresses
Consumer Impact
By choosing the Organica Plush, consumers are supporting:
- Sustainable agriculture practices
- Reduced chemical use in manufacturing
- Lower transportation emissions
- Longer product lifecycles
- Third-party environmental certification systems
However, the environmental benefits come with a higher price point, which may limit accessibility for some consumers. This raises questions about balancing environmental responsibility with market accessibility.
But that’s a challenge that extends beyond just this mattress to the broader sustainable products industry.
Potential Drawbacks
While the Organica Plush stands out as an exceptional luxury mattress, it’s important to thoroughly examine its possible limitations and drawbacks. Though this mattress excels in many areas, a thorough review must examine aspects that could present challenges for certain users or situations.
Some of these drawbacks are inherent to the mattress’s design choices. For instance, the very features that make it luxuriously comfortable (like its height and plush feel) can also create practical challenges.
Other limitations might affect only specific groups of users, such as those with latex sensitivities or individuals who primarily sleep on their stomachs. Still others relate to practical considerations like cost and maintenance requirements.
These drawbacks don’t necessarily make the Organica Plush a poor choice. Indeed, for many sleepers, its benefits will far outweigh these limitations.
However, understanding these potential issues helps ensure you can make an informed decision about whether this mattress aligns with your specific needs and circumstances.
Height and Maneuverability
The 16-inch height of the Organica Plush, while luxurious, creates several practical challenges. Standard fitted sheets often struggle to accommodate this thickness, requiring you to invest in deep-pocket sheets that can be more expensive and harder to find.
The mattress height can also make it difficult for shorter individuals or those with mobility issues to get in and out of bed comfortably. Imagine needing to make a small hop every time you want to get into bed. This could become frustrating over time.
The mattress’s substantial weight, due to the natural latex layers and pocketed coil system, makes it particularly challenging to move or rotate.
Even with the included handles, you’ll likely need at least two people to manage these tasks effectively. This could be especially problematic if you live alone or frequently redecorate your bedroom.
Firmness and Sleep Position Limitations
Despite its high-quality construction, the plush feel (4 out of 10 on the firmness scale) isn’t ideal for all sleepers. Stomach sleepers, in particular, may find that their hips sink too deeply into the mattress, potentially causing lower back strain over time.
Think of it like trying to maintain proper posture while standing on a very soft surface. Eventually, your body has to work harder to maintain alignment.
Heavier individuals (over 230 pounds) might also find the softness problematic, as they may sink too deeply into the comfort layers.
This could create a feeling of being “swallowed” by the mattress rather than properly supported, potentially leading to alignment issues and discomfort over time.
Cost Considerations
The premium price point of the Organica Plush represents a significant investment that may be prohibitive for many buyers. While the quality of materials justifies the cost, the initial outlay of $2,499 for a queen size might stretch or exceed many people’s mattress budgets.
The need for deep-pocket sheets and potentially a new bed frame to accommodate the height adds to the total cost of ownership.
Temperature Regulation Trade-offs
Although the mattress incorporates natural cooling materials, the plush surface can create more body contact and potentially trap more heat than firmer models. Some hot sleepers might find this problematic, especially during warmer months.
It’s like wearing a wool sweater in a way. While the material might breathe well, the closer contact with your body can still lead to heat buildup.
Break-in Period and Adjustment
The unique feel of natural latex combined with the plush comfort level means some sleepers may require a longer adjustment period. During the first few weeks, you might experience temporary discomfort as your body adapts to the new sleep surface.
This is particularly true if you’re transitioning from a firmer mattress or one made with different materials.
Latex Sensitivity Considerations
While rare, some individuals are allergic to latex. Although the latex in this mattress is encased in other materials, those with severe latex allergies should consult their healthcare provider before purchase.
The organic wool layer might also cause sensitivity in some individuals, leading to skin irritation or allergic reactions.
Mattress Policies and Prices
Understanding the warranty, trial period, and pricing of a premium mattress like the Organica Plush is crucial for making an informed purchase decision.
These policies reflect not just the manufacturer’s confidence in their product, but also provide important protections for what represents a significant investment in your sleep health.
I find it particularly interesting how mattress policies have evolved in recent years, especially in the natural and organic mattress segment.
See, where traditional mattress shopping once offered limited trial periods and complex warranty terms, today’s premium mattress brands like Amerisleep have developed comprehensive policies that acknowledge both the unique characteristics of natural materials and the adjustment period many sleepers need when transitioning to them.
For instance, the 20-year warranty acknowledges the exceptional durability of natural Talalay latex, while the 100-night sleep trial gives you time to adjust to the unique feel of organic materials that may differ significantly from conventional mattresses you’ve used before.
Mattress Warranty
The Organica comes with a 20-year warranty period, which is divided into two equal parts. The first half runs for 10 years, followed by another 10-year period.
In those first 10 years, if your Organica mattress develops problems that are covered by the warranty, Amerisleep provides a complete replacement at no cost to you.
In other words, they’ll replace your mattress if it shows manufacturing defects or if you notice a permanent sag deeper than 1.5 inches in the area where you sleep. While the mattress itself is free, you should know that you might need to cover shipping costs.
The second 10-year stretch works on a prorated basis. This means if your mattress needs to be replaced during this time, you’ll be asked to pay 50% of your original purchase price. You’ll also need to handle any shipping expenses for the replacement mattress.
To keep your warranty protection active, there are several key requirements:
- Make sure to keep that law tag attached to your mattress
- Avoid getting stains on it (a mattress protector is a smart investment)
- Use the correct type of support system.
The Organica works with platform beds, adjustable bases, and proper foundations. For box springs, you’ll need to add a three-quarter inch piece of moisture-resistant plywood on top to provide the right support.
Should you need to make a warranty claim, you’ll have to show your original purchase receipt, and Amerisleep might ask for photos of both your mattress and its foundation.
One last important detail: this warranty only applies to the original buyer. If the mattress changes hands (whether as a gift or through a sale) the warranty protection doesn’t carry over to the new owner.
Mattress Sleep Trial
A sleep trial is especially important with a natural mattress like the Organica because it may feel quite different from traditional mattresses you’ve used before. Its combination of latex, wool, and cotton creates a unique feel that you’ll want to experience over time.
While you can read about its natural materials and sustainability, the only way to truly know if it’s right for you is to sleep on it night after night in your own home.
Now, your 100-night trial period starts when your mattress arrives at your home. If you’ve also purchased an adjustable bed base with your Organica, the trial won’t begin until both items are delivered. This ensures you get the full 100 nights to test your complete sleep setup
While some people fall in love with their Organica right away, Amerisleep explains that it might take up to 30 nights for your body to fully adjust to the mattress. If you notice minor aches or stiffness at first, don’t worry – this is typically just your body adapting to the natural support system.
If you decide the Organica isn’t right for you, you can return it for a complete refund. However, there’s one important requirement: you need to sleep on the mattress for at least 30 nights before starting a return. This minimum trial period ensures you’ve given your body enough time to adapt to the new sleep surface.
To return the mattress within the 100-night window, simply contact Amerisleep. They make the process straightforward:
- Their support team based in Arizona will help guide you through the process
- They’ll arrange free pickup of the mattress
- After the return is complete, they’ll process your full refund
This risk-free trial allows you to properly test the Organica in your own home, with your normal sleep routine, without pressure to make a quick decision. It gives you the confidence to try a natural mattress knowing you can return it if it’s not the perfect fit for your sleep needs.
Mattress Sizes and Prices
The Amerisleep Organica Plush comes in all standard mattress sizes, with pricing that reflects its premium materials and construction. The mattress features 6 total inches of natural Talalay latex, significantly more than many competitors offering just 3-4 inches.
Mattress Size | Mattress Sales Price |
---|---|
Twin | $1999 |
Twin XL | $2049 |
Full | $2399 |
Queen | $2499 |
King | $2999 |
California King | $2999 |
Split King | $4398 |
When we compare these prices to other luxury organic mattresses, the Organica Plush presents compelling value despite its premium positioning.
For instance, the PlushBeds Botanical Bliss with similar materials starts at $2,499 for a twin and reaches $3,799 for a king. The Avocado Organic Luxury Plush Mattress commands even higher prices, starting at $3,499 for a twin and reaching $5,999 for a king size.
When you consider that natural latex is one of the most expensive mattress materials, costing manufacturers several times more than synthetic foams, the pricing becomes even more remarkable.
The height of the mattress also factors into its value proposition. At 16 inches tall, the Organica Plush offers a more substantial profile than many luxury competitors that typically range from 12-14 inches.
This additional height isn’t just for show, either. It represents more layers of comfort materials and enhanced durability.
It’s worth noting that while the initial investment might seem substantial compared to conventional mattresses, the durability of natural materials like Talalay latex often results in a lower cost per year of use.
See, where a synthetic foam mattress might need replacement after 5-7 years, the Organica Plush is built to maintain its comfort and support characteristics for 7-10 years or more.
For those interested in financing, Amerisleep partners with companies like Klarna to offer payment plans that can make the investment more manageable. This allows buyers to enjoy the benefits of a premium organic mattress while spreading the cost over time.
Customer Reviews
While there is limited feedback on this boxtop model, the original Organica model shows several notable characteristics in customer feedback.
Looking at softness perception in the standard Organica, reviewer “gal809” from Los Angeles provides particularly relevant feedback: “This definitely is softer than you would think based on the firmness rating… The main con – that is is [sic] really significantly softer than advertised.”
This directly speaks to Amerisleep’s tendency to create mattresses that feel softer than their ratings might suggest.
The experience of “CO Widow” from Boulder offers insight into the transition from firm to softer mattresses: “When my husband was alive, he always insisted on a super firm (read: hard) mattress… When I tried the Amerisleep Organica, I was concerned that it would be too soft, but it gives just enough to let my hips & shoulders sink more than the lighter areas of my body & gives perfect, comfortable sleep.”
So even those accustomed to very firm mattresses can adapt well to Amerisleep’s softer feel.
Regarding pressure relief and comfort for different sleeping positions, “SR” from San Diego notes that the mattress works well for multiple sleeping styles: “all other brands were too firm to suit my side-sleeping and husband’s combination-sleeping needs. This mattress is the PERFECT blend! So soft but also sturdy and shape-holding enough to offer support.”
Similarly, “Monica” from Boston specifically mentions its suitability for side sleepers: “I wanted a firm organic bed for myself and my husband who are both side sleepers and this works great.”
For durability, “Diymom” from Verde Valley provides detailed long-term feedback: “In the first 4 months no depressions are noticeable at all.”
Another long-term user, “Sleepin’ Well” from CA, mentions: “I’ve had it for two years now and it is one of the best purchases I’ve ever made.”
The mattress’s ability to accommodate different body types is well-documented by “gal809,” who provides specific details: “I am 5’7″ 150lbs and my partner is 6’1″ and 270lbs. I am a side sleeper, he is a flip-flop-around sleeper.” This couple’s positive experience suggests excellent adaptability across different body types.
“TrentT” from Gilbert, AZ offers an interesting comparative perspective: “We returned another brand’s green mattress after a few months of use. We have now had our Amerisleep for a couple of months and are very happy so far!”
Suggesting that Amerisleep’s approach to organic mattress design may be more successful than some competitors.
So based on these detailed reviews, we can expect the Organica Plush to amplify certain characteristics.
For instance, if the standard model already provides what “SR” describes as “So soft but also sturdy,” the Plush version will likely offer even more pronounced softness while maintaining Amerisleep’s characteristic support structure. Excellent for sleepers like those described by “CO Widow,” who appreciate more give around pressure points.
The durability reports from long-term users like “Sleepin’ Well” and “Diymom” suggest that Amerisleep has mastered their latex formulation, indicating that the Plush version should maintain its softness without compromising longevity.
However, those who share “gal809’s” observation about the standard model being softer than expected might find the Plush version too soft for their preferences.
“TMK” from Largo, FL provides a particularly relevant perspective for potential Plush buyers: “I wanted a latex organic mattress and began doing research among all the different brands… Literally from the first time I laid on it I was beyond satisfied. It is so comfortable. Exactly what I was looking for.”
This kind of satisfaction with Amerisleep’s approach to latex mattresses bodes well for their new Plush variation.
Mattress Care and Maintenance
While natural materials are generally quite durable, they can be sensitive to environmental factors like moisture, sunlight, and improper support.
Following these guidelines will help protect your investment by preventing common issues before they arise and addressing any concerns that do develop before they can compromise your mattress’s performance.
Remember that this mattress represents a significant investment in your sleep health, and proper care ensures you’ll continue to enjoy its benefits for its full expected lifespan of 7-10 years or more.
Mattress Protection
The most crucial step in mattress care begins before you even sleep on it. And that’s investing in a high-quality mattress protector.
Given the Organica Plush’s 16-inch height, you’ll need a deep-pocket protector specifically designed for thick mattresses as a first line of defense.
Look for a waterproof protector that’s also breathable, as this maintains the natural temperature-regulating properties of the latex and wool layers while protecting against spills, stains, and accidents that could void your warranty.
Creating an Ideal Foundation
The base you choose plays a crucial role in maintaining your mattress’s integrity. The Organica Plush requires robust support to perform optimally. Use either:
- A solid platform bed
- A slatted base with slats no more than 3 inches apart. Regularly check that the slats haven’t warped or cracked, as this could affect mattress support and longevity.
- An adjustable bed
Monthly Maintenance
Even with a mattress protector, implementing a regular cleaning schedule helps maintain freshness and hygiene.
Vacuum the mattress surface using an upholstery attachment, paying special attention to seams and tufting where dust can accumulate. Use gentle strokes to avoid damaging the organic cotton cover. Remove and wash your mattress protector during this time.
Dealing with Spills and Stains
If a spill occurs, act quickly:
- Blot (don’t rub) the area with a clean, dry cloth to absorb liquid
- Mix a small amount of mild detergent with cool water
- Gently dab the stained area with the solution using a clean cloth
- Follow with a clean, damp cloth to remove soap residue
- Allow the area to dry completely before remaking the bed Never saturate the mattress with water or cleaning solutions, as excess moisture can damage the internal components.
Airing and Freshening
Every few months, when changing sheets, let your mattress breathe for a few hours. This helps dissipate any moisture that may have accumulated.
For natural deodorizing, sprinkle baking soda over the surface, let it sit for several hours, then vacuum thoroughly.
Regular Rotation Schedule
Even though the Organica Plush doesn’t need to be flipped (due to its layered construction), regular rotation is essential. I recommend rotating the mattress head-to-foot every three to four months.
This practice ensures even wear across the surface and prevents body impressions from becoming permanent. The mattress includes built-in handles that make this task easier, though given its substantial weight, it’s best to rotate with a partner’s help.
Temperature and Environment Control
Keep your bedroom environment controlled to protect your mattress. Maintain a relative humidity between 30-50% to prevent moisture accumulation.
Avoid placing the mattress in direct sunlight, which can degrade the natural materials over time. If possible, use blackout curtains during the day to protect the mattress from UV exposure.
What to Avoid
To ensure the longest possible lifespan for your Organica Plush:
- Never fold or bend the mattress
- Avoid sitting in one spot for extended periods
- Don’t allow children to jump on the bed
- Keep pets’ sharp claws away from the mattress surface
- Don’t use harsh cleaning chemicals or steam cleaners
- Avoid eating or drinking in bed
Emergency Care
If you notice any unusual sagging, lumping, or changes in comfort, document these issues with photographs and measurements.
Contact Amerisleep’s customer service promptly, as addressing problems early can prevent them from worsening and potentially help with warranty claims.
Closing Thoughts
After thorough testing across all major categories (comfort, support, cooling, motion isolation, and durability) I award the Organica Plush a strong 9 out of 10. It lost a point mainly due to its price and the fact that it won’t suit all sleep styles, particularly stomach sleepers.
At 16 inches tall with premium materials throughout, this mattress isn’t cheap. But when you consider that you’ll spend roughly a third of your life on it over the next 7-10 years, the investment starts to make more sense.
It’s like buying a quality pair of shoes. Sometimes spending more upfront saves money in the long run. For those who love a softer feel and care about using natural materials, this mattress is hard to beat.
After spending extensive time testing and evaluating the Amerisleep Organica Plush mattress, I can confidently say it’s one of the most impressive luxury mattresses I’ve encountered. While its plush feel isn’t for everyone, it excels at its aim of cloud-like comfort with proper support.
The natural materials work together beautifully. The breathable latex, temperature-regulating wool, and soft organic cotton create a sleep surface that’s both comfortable and eco-friendly
Have you tried the Organica Plush, the original Organica or other natural latex mattresses? We’d love to hear about your experience in the comments below!
And if you found this review helpful, please share it with friends and family who might be mattress shopping. Everyone deserves to know about their options for better sleep!
Final Score Tally
Mattress Feature | Tester's Score |
---|---|
Responsiveness | 9 out of 10 |
Motion Isolation | 10 out of 10 |
Edge Support | 10 out of 10 |
Cooling Ability | 9 out of 10 |
Final Score | 9 out of 10 |
Frequently Asked Questions
The Organica Plush earns its luxury status through both its premium materials and impressive 16-inch height, which includes 6 total inches of natural Talalay latex. Double what you find in many high-end latex hybrids.
The craftsmanship is evident in details like the hand-tufted construction that eliminates the need for adhesives, the reinforced edge support system, and the use of certified organic materials like GOTS cotton and wool.
Beyond materials and construction, it delivers a truly luxurious sleep experience with its cloud-like comfort from the 3-inch latex box top while maintaining the responsive support that premium Talalay latex is known for.
These mattresses serve different sleeper preferences. The Organica Plush uses natural latex for a buoyant, responsive feel while the AS5 Hybrid uses memory foam for a deeper hug and contouring sensation.
The Organica Plush excels at temperature regulation thanks to its breathable natural materials, while the AS5 Hybrid relies on Bio-Pur’s advanced open-cell structure to improve cooling compared to traditional memory foam.
For those seeking an eco-friendly luxury option with more bounce, the Organica Plush is likely the better choice, while those who love the distinctive conforming feel of memory foam may prefer the AS5 Hybrid.
The Organica Plush can potentially help with back pain through its combination of pressure-relieving comfort layers and supportive pocketed coils, though its effectiveness will depend on your specific condition and sleep position.
The responsive Talalay latex helps maintain proper spinal alignment while still cushioning sensitive areas. And the mattress’s softer feel may be particularly beneficial for side sleepers with back pain who need extra pressure relief around the shoulders and hips.
However, some back pain sufferers, especially stomach sleepers or those who need very firm support, might find better relief on a firmer mattress. It’s best to consult with a healthcare provider about your specific needs.
Talalay latex is considered one of the highest quality materials for sleep surfaces due to its unique combination of comfort and durability, featuring a consistently bouncy yet conforming feel that many sleepers love.
The material is exceptionally breathable (up to seven times more than traditional foams) which helps maintain a comfortable sleep temperature throughout the night.
Natural Talalay latex like that used in the Organica Plush is also hypoallergenic, resistant to dust mites and mold, and free from the off-gassing often associated with synthetic foams.
While all mattresses show some wear over time, the Organica Plush is engineered to maintain its shape and support thanks to the natural resilience of Talalay latex, which typically outlasts traditional foams in durability testing.
The pocketed coil support system and reinforced edges help prevent sagging around the perimeter, while the hand-tufted construction keeps all layers securely in place without relying on adhesives that can break down over time.
With proper care, including regular rotation and use of a suitable foundation, the Organica Plush should maintain its comfort and support characteristics for 7-10 years or more.
The Organica Plush requires a sturdy, flat foundation that can properly support its 16-inch height and substantial weight while ensuring even weight distribution for optimal performance.
A solid platform bed, high-quality box spring, or slatted base with slats no more than 3 inches apart would all work well. The mattress is also compatible with adjustable bed bases for those who want that functionality.
For slatted bases, ensure the slats are thick enough to support the mattress weight without bowing. If in doubt, adding a bunkie board can provide extra support and help extend the mattress’s lifespan.
The Organica Plush is exceptionally well-suited for side sleepers thanks to its softer comfort level (remember, it’s 4 out of 10 on the firmness scale) and generous comfort layers that allow the shoulders and hips to sink in appropriately.
The 3-inch latex box top provides immediate pressure relief for sensitive joints, while the supporting latex layers and pocketed coils work together to maintain proper spinal alignment even as you sink into the plush surface.
The responsive nature of the Talalay latex also makes it easier for side sleepers to change positions during the night without feeling stuck in the mattress.